Crawlspaces That Work
To avoid moisture problems, either seal and condition your crawlspace or isolate the space from the rest of the house.
Synopsis: An “unvented crawlspace” is a misnomer—all crawlspaces need a means of removing moisture. Crawlspaces can either be vented or “sealed and conditioned.” While vented crawlspaces have earned a bad reputation, they do have their place, and the key is to choose an air- and vapor-impermeable insulation. When creating a sealed and conditioned crawlspace, attention must be paid to the wall insulation, floor covering, and method of air conditioning.
Years ago I was working with a builder on a job in New England where a small crawlspace foundation was being poured for an addition to an old house. The builder had set metal foundation vent openings into the foundation formwork, but told me that as soon as the building official did his final inspection he planned to seal the vents from the inside using rigid foam. Warm outdoor air, he explained, holds more moisture than cooler crawlspace air. When that humid outdoor air enters through the crawlspace vents, it condenses on the cool surfaces and can lead to rot, mold, and poor air quality.
Yet, according to a report published by the U.S. Department of Energy, builders and designers often stick to this failure-prone “vented crawlspace” approach because they believe the code doesn’t allow them to build an unvented one. Therein lies the confusion.
First, vented crawlspaces can work, as long as they’re detailed correctly—most aren’t. Second, the building code typically does not allow “unvented” crawlspaces, but it does allow the construction of sealed, “conditioned” crawlspaces. A successful crawlspace, from a moisture perspective, must be either part of the conditioned envelope of the house, or completely separated from it. Anything in between is a recipe for disaster.
Unvented? Say “conditioned”
As building scientist Joseph Lstiburek warns, the term “unvented” has led to a lot of crawlspace problems over the years. “Unvented implies that you just don’t install vents. Wrong. Big time wrong,” he wrote in a Building Science Corporation article. “There has to be a means of removing moisture from the crawlspace when the crawlspace is connected to the house. …Houses are ‘conditioned’ and conditioning means controlling temperature and relative humidity.”
The way to control temperature and relative humidity is to exchange crawlspace air with the living space above the crawlspace in some way instead of relying on air flowing through from the exterior. But in order to perform as intended, the crawlspace needs to be protected against moisture, insulated, and air-sealed to isolate the space from the exterior.
This is relatively easy in new construction, but can be difficult in retrofits. Approaches vary, but perhaps the most popular is to insulate with spray polyurethane foam or rigid foam board applied to the walls of the foundation (on the inside or outside face) as well as the rim board of the floor framing. The floor of the crawlspace doesn’t need to be insulated, but it must be covered with a continuous layer of at least 6-mil polyethylene sheeting sealed at all transitions and seams.
To read the entire article, please click the View PDF button below.
RELATED LINKS
- Wet-Crawlspace Solution
- How to Insulate a Floor Over a Crawlspace
- Episode Eleven: Floor Leveling, Crawlspaces, and Structural Beams
- Creating a Sealed Crawlspace
Fine Homebuilding Recommended Products
Fine Homebuilding receives a commission for items purchased through links on this site, including Amazon Associates and other affiliate advertising programs.
Loctite Foamboard Adhesive
Caulking Gun
Utility Knife
View Comments
Justin, Thank you for the infomation about crawl spaces. I replaced the old fiberglass insulation in my crawl space with Rockwool batts aka stonewool. It seems far superior though it was a really miserable job swapping out the old fiberglass batts. What is your view of Rockwool as an alternative to a spray on foam or rigid foam insulation? House is 20 years old and the joists and subfloor showed no signs of rot or damage. I'm thankful for that. I still need to install rigid insulation on the interior of my block foundation walls however. I keep the vents closed to keep out hot, humid air. Any other suggestion are appreciated. Thanks again, Steven Martin, Romney, WV , [email protected]